Skip to content
Scotia Club

The Way Donald Trump and the Crude Oil Markets Move in Sync: A Tango Illustrated in Six Graphs

Chart placeholder Oil market illustration

It is often difficult to pin down the factors influencing Donald Trump a month into the US and Israel's campaign of military action on Iran.

However, it remains clear he has his attention fixed on the global crude markets.

A comment – or online message – from the American leader about his intentions used to spark big moves in prices, as market participants reacted to signals the conflict could escalate or come to an end.

But in the last week, traders appear to be growing more doubtful about the significance of his remarks.

Oil was hovering around approximately $72 a barrel prior to 28 February, when the strikes on Iran started.

Recently, it peaked at $118 a barrel on 19 March and by Friday afternoon was valued at just below $112 – markedly up from its pre-war price.

The following are key instances from the past month where Trump and the financial markets seem to have bounced off each other – with differing effects.

Navigate with the navigation button to advance to the following chart.

"Energy prices have become a proxy for broader political and financial uncertainties, surging when Trump's rhetoric becomes aggressive and easing when his language becomes more conciliatory," observes one investment manager.

He adds that financial markets are understandably sensitive to those cues, given the big macroeconomic threats that come with increasing oil prices.

"Market participants are trying to price real volatility," he says. "The markets can appear nervous or confused, but what they're actually doing is navigating event risk in live, with oil acting as the core of that."

However, it can be challenging for investors to determine how to trade, particularly because some of Trump's statements seem aimed at influencing oil prices, instead of conveying policy, says another financial strategist.

"As the saying goes, the first casualty of war is truth," he remarks. "I suspect some of the dialogue back-and-forth around diplomatic progress, and the opposite, very much are centred around simply influencing the market price of oil."

Investor Response Become Increasingly Subdued

On Thursday, moments after US equity markets saw their sharpest fall since the beginning of the Iran war, Trump stated talks with Iran were going "very well" and he was putting off military strikes on Iran's energy infrastructure until at least 6 April.

But, the price of crude proceeded to rise.

One currency strategist says that investor responses are "becoming more muted" because of the "huge gap" between Trump's optimistic statements and the lack of confirmation from Tehran.

"Given the optics, a large number of market watchers do not foresee an imminent conclusion to the conflict and financial markets remain apprehensive."

Another market expert comments investors have also become accustomed to Trump "frequently changing tack at hints of political, stock market or economic trouble".

"There is a amount of wariness, or even outright distrust, emerging at the fringes," he concludes.

JJ
Written by

Jessica Jackson

A Scottish historian and cultural enthusiast with a passion for sharing untold stories and traditions from the Highlands and beyond.

Scotia Club

Type to search articles.